Do You Really Need a Thrift Wishlist? I Didn’t Think So Either

If you know me in real life, you know that I seldom buy anything new. FINE, I did splurge on four new pairs of jeans after having my daughter—but I was having a body image crisis, and the only way I could get through sizing up was buying really cute, trendy, made-for-me jeans from American Eagle (SUE ME).

But honestly, since then (2023), I’ve made it a life motto of mine to thrift first. If I have an event to go to, a vacation planned, or just want to spruce up my wardrobe for the season, I visit a local thrift shop first—always—before going online or supporting fast fashion. It’s done me well so far. Last year alone, I found several staple pieces that have made their way onto my “choose-everyday” list.

I’d like to think I have a good eye, and I’m usually not looking for anything specific when I thrift—but maybe this is my year for change. I’ve been seeing a lot of hubbub about what the kids are calling a “thrift wishlist,” so I’m going to try making one and document my progress throughout the year. This feels like a fun way to be more intentional when spending money at the thrift store, because just because something is secondhand and inexpensive doesn’t mean it’s necessary.

What is a Thrift Wishlist?

So first of all—what the heck is a thrift wishlist anyway? These are items you identify as things you’d be lucky to find at a thrift store. They’re typically more expensive or specific clothing items (name brands, certain styles, event-specific pieces), one-of-a-kind or vintage home decor, and/or quality cookware and serving dishes (think Le Creuset, stainless steel pots and pans, etc.).

How can a Thrift Wishlist be Helpful?

From an outside perspective, I can immediately see why having a thrift wishlist could be helpful.

• You are new to thrifting

  If you’re not a frequent thrifter, it takes time to figure out what you like. Starting with an idea of what you’re looking for—or even just a loose guideline—is a great place to begin. Once you find something close to what’s on your list, you can try it on and see if it actually works for you.

• You're on a budget

  Having a plan for what you will (and won’t) spend money on matters. If you know a white wool cardigan is on your thrift wishlist, you may be less inclined to spend money on the first “cute” thing you see. A list helps you stay focused.

• It's more exciting

  A thrift wishlist gives you:

  • A reason to visit thrift stores you don’t normally go to and see what your area really has to offer.

  • A reason to search instead of browse—it’s basically a scavenger hunt for things you genuinely like.

  You can research brands, hunt for vintage pieces, or even find items that might be worth money. The possibilities are endless. So honestly… what harm can a list do?

  
  

What is on my Thrift Wishlist (and Why)?

Categories:

• Clothing (Of course)

  • White Flowy Skirt

  • Waist length Lilac Cardigan

  • Women’s sneakers (adidas preferred)

  • Patchwork Vest

• Decor

  • Picture Frames for gallery wall (assorted materials - no black)

  • Wall Candle Holder/Sconce

• Cooking/Serving

  • Stainless steel pans

  • Floral/Tomato/Striped Plates/Bowls

  • Glass Beverage Pitcher

• Accessories

  • Statement Hand Rings

This list is intentionally a little vague—think of it more as an idea starter than a strict checklist. Pinterest is your friend here, and I actually think it’s fun to pin things you wouldn’t normally wear or buy. You might surprise yourself with what you’re drawn to, or what you’re lucky enough to find. I’ll be updating my progress every three months, and I’ll refresh the wishlist as things get crossed off (or if my taste shifts—because let’s be real, it will). Happy thrifting 🤍

With love,

LB